Consumers Feel Worse Than During 2008

September 25, 2026

Americans are more anxious than at almost any point in modern history.


Both releases are in. The Census Bureau’s August durable goods report hit at 8:30 a.m. ET. The University of Michigan’s final September consumer sentiment reading dropped at 10:00 a.m. ET. Taken together, they hand the market a genuinely complicated picture heading into the final week of September: business investment held up, but the American consumer is in a place that has almost no historical precedent.

Sponsored

In at 9:35 AM. Out by 10.

I call it the “Opening Bell Breakout.” It’s the same setup I used to catch moves like 113% on GOOGL and 240% on META. I trade one simple 15-minute window each morning – and I’m usually done by 10 AM.

Get the free guide and see exactly how it works.

Market Snapshot

The macro backdrop is tightening fast. The Fed raised rates 25 basis points on September 16 to a range of 3.75% to 4.00%, its first hike since 2023, and Chair Kevin Warsh’s press conference left Polymarket pricing a 65% chance of another move at the October 27-28 meeting. Futures markets, meanwhile, are pricing the fed funds rate at roughly 4.3% by December, per data compiled by StreetStats as of Wednesday’s close. The 2-year Treasury climbed above 4.9% on Wednesday after Fed Governor Michael Barr said the committee was “out of position” on rates. The data this morning did nothing to ease that pressure.

Sponsored

Why Did Trump Just Ban America’s Most Powerful AI?

It’s not Nvidia. It’s not OpenAI. It’s not Google.

It’s a San Francisco AI lab whose technology is used by eight of the ten largest companies in America – and which Bloomberg calls the highest-revenue AI company on earth.

Trump banned it from every federal agency and the Pentagon blacklisted it. The reason isn’t what you think.

Full details here

Stocks in Focus

  • XLY (Consumer Discretionary ETF): The final Michigan reading came in at 48.1, a slight beat versus the 47.8 preliminary but still a four-month low. The Consumer Expectations sub-index dropped to 46.3 from 51.5 in August. That forward-looking component is where spending decisions get made. A sub-index near 46 is a direct headwind to big-ticket discretionary names inside XLY. Watch the first 30 minutes of the afternoon session for direction as options desks adjust hedges.
  • XLP (Consumer Staples ETF): Year-ahead inflation expectations held at 4.6% in the final September reading, the highest since June. Five-year expectations ticked to 3.4%, snapping a three-month run at 3.3%. Persistently elevated inflation expectations favor staples over discretionary. If the rotation into XLP that began in August accelerates into quarter-end rebalancing, this is the natural landing spot for capital leaving consumer cyclicals.
  • SPY: The durable goods headline came in flat at $338.6 billion, defying expectations for a 0.4% decline. The number that matters most, nondefense capital goods excluding aircraft, rose 1.6% versus a 0.5% forecast. That is a strong read on corporate spending intent and adds another brick to the hawkish case. SPY is caught between a resilient economy and a Fed that is still moving. The 50-day moving average is the level to watch through today’s close.

Sector Watch

Consumer discretionary has been losing relative strength for weeks, and today’s final sentiment number does not change that trajectory. The University of Michigan’s survey director noted that year-ahead expectations for both personal finances and business conditions plunged, driven by resurgent fuel prices and escalating trade tensions tied to the Iran conflict. CNN reported that the 48.1 September reading is the second-lowest on record in a survey dating back to 1952, meaning sentiment is now weaker than during the 2008 financial crisis, the COVID-19 pandemic, and the 1970s oil crisis. That is not a backdrop where households stretch for discretionary spending. Utilities and healthcare are holding relative strength alongside staples heading into the session’s final hours.

Catalyst Calendar

  • September 30 — Micron Technology earnings: Memory is the clearest read on AI infrastructure demand. Micron’s guidance will tell traders whether the capital spending surge showing up in today’s durable goods core number is flowing into semiconductors.
  • October 2 — September jobs report: The single most important data point before the October 27-28 Fed meeting. A strong payrolls number, combined with today’s resilient durable goods core, would push October hike odds above 75%.
  • October 27-28 — FOMC meeting: Polymarket sits at 65% for a 25-basis-point hike. The jobs report on October 2 and the September CPI reading, due mid-October, will determine whether that probability moves materially before the meeting.

Technical Radar

SPY is trading below its 50-day moving average. The durable goods beat removes one downside catalyst but does not resolve the policy overhang. XLY’s relative strength versus SPY has deteriorated steadily since early August. Today’s final sentiment confirmation gives bears another fundamental data point to lean on. The 10:00 a.m. Michigan release typically triggers options desk hedging into the close; watch whether XLY holds or breaks the September 5 intraday low through 3:30 p.m. ET.

Sponsored

The Market Doesn’t Have to Cooperate

Up one day. Down the next. Then nowhere at all. That kind of market can make consistent trading tough. Dave Aquino built his Ultimate Income System for exactly these conditions. After 971 trade setups and 910 reported winners, he’s revealing the strategy and what he says separates profitable traders from the losing 90%.

See the Ultimate Income System >>

Risk Radar

The core risk is now asymmetric. The durable goods beat and the resilient corporate spending read give the Fed cover to hike in October. At the same time, consumer sentiment near a 74-year low signals that the transmission of higher rates into household finances is already well advanced. The dangerous scenario is a Fed that keeps hiking into a consumer who is already stretched, with fuel prices elevated due to the Iran conflict and five-year inflation expectations drifting higher. That combination is negative for growth assets and positive for volatility. The secondary risk is quarter-end rebalancing pressure through September 30, which can amplify moves in either direction regardless of the fundamental backdrop.

The Cheat Sheet

  • Top Market Theme: A hawkish Fed with data on its side meets a consumer who is more anxious than at almost any point since 1952. Something has to give, and October’s jobs report will be the first real signal of which side blinks.
  • Stock to Watch: XLY. The clearest expression of the consumer stress trade, and the ETF most directly repriced by today’s 48.1 final sentiment number.
  • Sector to Watch: Consumer Staples. Elevated inflation expectations and deteriorating forward sentiment favor the defensive rotation into XLP through quarter-end.
  • Biggest Risk: The Fed hikes again in October into a consumer already near a historic sentiment low. That scenario accelerates the spending pullback the Michigan data is already telegraphing.
  • Biggest Opportunity: The durable goods core beat signals that corporate capital spending is still expanding. If Micron confirms on September 30 that AI infrastructure demand is absorbing that spending, semiconductor names have a catalyst that runs independent of consumer sentiment.
  • One Thing to Remember: Sentiment at 48.1 is not just a weak number. It is the second-lowest reading in 74 years of data. The market has not fully priced what that means for consumer spending in Q4.

Live Market Pulse

The charting technology is provided by TradingView. Learn how to use theTradingView Stock Screener.

Categories